Founding Attorney
Losing your original will does not automatically mean your estate plan is invalid, but it can create significant complications. In New York, when an original will cannot be found after a person’s death, the court may presume that the person intentionally revoked it. Overcoming that presumption is possible in some cases, but it often requires additional evidence and can make the probate process more difficult.
What Happens If the Original Will Cannot Be Found?
If you discover that your original will is missing, you can generally create a new will that clearly revokes any prior versions. This is often the simplest solution.
The situation becomes more complicated when the original will cannot be located after the testator’s death. New York probate courts typically expect the original document to be filed with the court. When it is missing, the court may presume the deceased person destroyed it with the intention of revoking it.
That presumption does not always reflect reality. Wills can be lost, misplaced, damaged, or accidentally destroyed. They may also be retained by an attorney, stored in a safe deposit box, or kept among personal records that family members have not yet located.
Can a Copy of a Lost Will Be Admitted to Probate?
Yes, under certain circumstances.
New York law allows a lost will to be admitted to probate, but specific requirements must be met. The party seeking probate must generally prove:
- The will was not revoked by the deceased.
- The will was properly executed when it was originally signed.
- The contents of the will can be clearly established. In New York, this generally requires at least two credible witnesses who can prove the will’s provisions, or a copy or draft that can be shown to be true and complete.
A copy of the will can be helpful evidence, particularly if it was retained by the drafting attorney or another trusted source. Witness testimony and other supporting documentation may also play a role in establishing the validity of the document.
Because the burden of proof is higher when the original is missing, probate proceedings often become more complex and time-consuming.
Why Does New York Presume a Missing Will Was Revoked?
The presumption exists because people commonly destroy wills when they decide to revoke them.
If a will was last known to be in the possession of the deceased and cannot be found after death, the court may infer that the person intentionally destroyed it. This legal presumption protects against outdated documents being presented as valid wills.
However, the presumption can be challenged with evidence showing that the will was lost or destroyed accidentally. For example, evidence of a house fire, flood, theft, relocation, or poor recordkeeping may help explain why the original document is missing.
Each case depends heavily on the available facts and evidence.
What Should You Do If You Lose Your Original Will While You Are Alive?
If you believe your original will has been lost, start by conducting a thorough search.
Check locations such as:
- Home safes and filing cabinets
- Safe deposit boxes
- Digital document inventories
- Records maintained by your attorney
- Storage units or other secure locations
If the original cannot be located, we often recommend reviewing your estate plan and preparing a new will. Executing a new document can eliminate uncertainty and reduce the possibility of future challenges.
It may also be a good opportunity to review whether your current estate plan still reflects your wishes, family circumstances, and financial situation.
How Can Losing a Will Affect Your Family?
A missing will can create delays, additional expenses, and disagreements among family members.
If the court ultimately determines that a lost will cannot be admitted to probate, the estate may be distributed under New York’s intestacy laws. In that situation, assets pass according to state law rather than according to the instructions the deceased intended.
Family members may also become involved in disputes over the contents of the missing document or whether it was revoked. These disagreements can prolong the administration process and place additional stress on loved ones during an already difficult time.
Taking steps to properly store and maintain estate planning documents can help avoid these issues.
Protect Your Wishes Before Problems Arise
A lost will does not always mean your estate plan has failed, but it can create legal hurdles that are often easier to prevent than to fix. Whether you have misplaced your original will, need to update an existing estate plan, or are dealing with probate after a loved one’s death, obtaining guidance early can make a meaningful difference.
At Merlino & Gonzalez, we help individuals and families throughout New York address estate planning and probate concerns with practical, personalized advice. Contact us today to discuss your situation and learn how we can help protect your wishes and your family’s future.