Founding Attorney
You may be able to sell your individual share of jointly inherited property in New York without every co-owner approving the transaction. Your rights and the required process depend on how title is held, whether estate administration is still underway, and whether the property qualifies for New York’s heirs property protections.
These questions often arise when siblings inherit a family home but have different plans for it.
Can You Sell Your Share if the Other Owners Disagree?
Your ability to sell begins with how the inherited property is titled. Beneficiaries who inherit property together often own it as tenants in common, with each person holding a percentage of the entire property. Selling your share does not sell the whole property. The buyer becomes a co-owner with the others.
Different rules may apply if the property qualifies as “heirs property” under New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law § 993. If you intend to accept or counter an outside offer for an interest in qualifying property, certain co-owners generally have 180 days after receiving notice to match its price, terms, and conditions.
If the owners cannot agree on a buyout or residential real estate sale, an eligible co-owner may seek partition. For heirs property, the process includes a settlement conference and an opportunity for the other co-owners to purchase the interests of those requesting a sale at a court-determined value. If no buyout occurs, the court generally favors physically dividing the property before ordering an open-market sale.
What if the Property Is Still Part of the Estate?
Do not assume that receiving a share under a will gives you an unrestricted right to sell it immediately. New York generally treats title to a decedent’s real property as passing at death, but that title is subject to the executor’s or administrator’s authority and the estate’s debts, taxes, expenses, and governing documents.
The fiduciary may need to sell the property during probate or administration. New York law gives fiduciaries broad powers to manage estate property and execute deeds needed for administration. A purported transfer by a beneficiary before the estate resolves its interest can therefore create title problems or conflict with the fiduciary’s duties.
Before signing a contract or deed, confirm who presently holds title, whether the will directs a sale, and whether the fiduciary has released the property from administration.
Is It Difficult to Sell a Partial Interest in a Property?
Often, yes. Most buyers do not want a fractional interest in an occupied house, especially when they would share control with strangers. Financing can also be difficult. An outside buyer may therefore offer substantially less than the share’s mathematical portion of the property’s market value.
An appraisal can help establish the value of the entire property, but a fractional interest may still sell at a discount because it offers limited control.
What Should You Review Before Selling an Inherited Share?
Before agreeing on a price or transfer, determine:
- The ownership percentages shown by the will, deed, or intestacy rules
- The property’s current market value and any mortgage, tax lien, or judgment
- Who paid carrying costs, repairs, insurance, and property taxes
- Whether anyone collected rent or had exclusive use of the property
- Whether the property qualifies as heirs property and another co-owner has a right of first refusal
- The potential income, capital gains, transfer tax, and closing-cost consequences
These details can affect both a private buyout and the accounting in a partition case. They should be documented before the parties commit to a number.
Choose a Clear Path for Your Inherited Property
An inherited ownership interest can have value, but converting it to cash may require more than finding a buyer. Merlino & Gonzalez can review the will, estate file, deed, liens, and payment history to determine what you own and what restrictions apply. We can also assist with estate administration, ownership transfers, negotiated buyouts, real estate sales, and partition matters when appropriate.
If you inherited New York property with siblings or other beneficiaries, contact Merlino & Gonzalez to discuss a practical course of action before you sign an agreement or deed.